Member-only story

Analyzing the new North Carolina map from a nonpartisan perspective

Tomas McIntee
7 min readDec 2, 2019

The North Carolina General Assembly recently passed a new Congressional district map. While it happened, I was following very regular and map-filled updates on the topic from Stephen Wolf, a Daily Kos elections expert. He has done a partisan analysis of the map, forecasting a likely 8–5 split.

The map passed by the NC GA, which will be in effect for the upcoming 2020 congressional elections.

It’s worth noting, first, that when the map breaks county lines, there are some cases in which it makes districts less compact. It’s necessary to divide some counties in order to make district populations exactly match, but it’s possible to do this in ways that make districts more, rather than less, compact. For example, there is a very odd S-shaped boundary cutting through Chatham and Lee counties, and Pitt County is cut through the middle by a boundary that wiggles back and forth like a snake.

There are somewhat wiggly boundaries inside the largest counties — Mecklenburg, Wake, and Forsyth — though it’s worth noting that Wake and Mecklenburg must be split, as both counties have populations larger than a single congressional district. Kudos to the legislators for making the obvious step of including one district entirely inside both counties.

The map is— from a partisan perspective — a major improvement on the previous gerrymander, and is advertised as likely to elect an 8R-5D split rather…

Create an account to read the full story.

Or, continue in mobile web

Already have an account? Sign in

Tomas McIntee
Tomas McIntee

Written by Tomas McIntee

Dr. Tomas McIntee is a mathematician and occasional social scientist with stray degrees in physics and philosophy.

Responses (1)

Write a response

This map is indeed an improvement over the former map. More squares than snakes!
However, the 50% who normally do not vote have a much bigger influence on the outcome than gerrymandered maps. If 10% of those people come out to vote, they could flip…

1